PJ Quran – Mufti Umar Sharif-2



2,817 views

Published: 4 years ago

Category: Errors in Quran by PJ, Fitna Videos

Tags: , ,

Description:

2 Responses to “PJ Quran – Mufti Umar Sharif-2”

  1. Syed says:

    http://www.pjfitna.com/zakat-pj-islamqa-fatwa/

    i am writing this comment on a different page due to the comment option being unavailable in the above link.

    from islamqa.com’s reply on http://www.pjfitna.com/zakat-pj-islamqa-fatwa/ ,
    it is obvious that ‘Zakath is obligatory only once in the lifetime for a THING ‘ . because islamqa’s madhhab following scholars have not quoted a single quranic verse or hadith with reg. to this matter.
    they only said, that it is a view of old generations. Shame on you blogger if cannot reply on this.

    • Admin says:

      Dear Brother –

      From the links http://www.pjfitna.com/zakat-pj-islamqa-fatwa/ and http://www.pjfitna.com/bilal-philips-on-pj-zakat/ – it is clear that Zakat needs to be paid every year on the same article – again – if it comes under zakatable product year after year.

      “””” view of old generations “”””””

      View of the Sahabah, Tabiyeen and Tabatabiyeen is that Zakat needs to be paid on the article every year – which PJ and TNTJ oppose – logically

      This is exactly the point

      We believe – Quran and Sunnah was first revealed to Sahabah and they understood it better than any one – and Allah vouched that He is satisfied by them religiously in the Quran.

      PJ AND TNTJ DIDNT DROP DOWN FROM THE SKY WITH QURAN AND SUNNAH

      NOR DID ALLAH VOUCH FOR THE UNDERSTANDING OF PJ OR TNTJ

      SAHABAH, TABIYEEN, TABE TABIYEEN ( SALAF – view of old generations ) UNDERSTANDING IS BETTER THAN PJ OR TNTJ

      SHAME ON THE ONE WHO THINK HIS UNDERSTANDING IS BETTER THAN THE UNDERSTANDING OF SAHABAH…

Leave a Reply