Zakat PJ Refuted

Is it necessary to distribute the Zakat for every year? I mean; I purchased a gold for my save, weight about 1kg ok, should I pay zakat 2.5% for the first year or shoudl i pay every year for that ? (The gold is an example) An imama at india said, The zakat for a thing is only one time in the life is applicable and not for the further years. If any body say that the zakat is obligation for each year, he must bring the proof from Quran and Hadith. The imam will pay SR100 thousands riayals, if he brought the proof form Quran or Hadiths, How it is correct ? what is the proof ? ( please I am not asking the proof and to getting the money I want to know because he challenged last 1996 until now no one give the proof and still he is challenge whenever he speak in the debates or meetings. Please explain me with the Quran ayats and hadiths.

Praise be to Allaah.The Muslims of the earlier and later generations are agreed that zakaah must be paid each year on gold, silver and the like.Ibn Hazm said in Maraatib al-Ijmaa’: They are agreed that zakaah must be paid repeatedly on all kinds of wealth at the end of each year, apart from crops and fruits, for which they are agreed that zakaah must be paid only once. (p. 38).

Shaykh al-Islam Ibn Taymiyah did not criticize this at all in his criticism of Maraatib al-Ijmaa’.

The evidence for this consensus is the practice of the ummah from the time of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) until the present day. The Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) used to send the zakaah-collectors to the tribes and cities, and they did not differentiate between those who had paid their zakaah the previous year and those who had not, rather they used to take the zakaah that was due on all the “zakaatable” wealth that people possessed.

Ibn Sireen said: The zakaah-collector used to come and wherever he saw crops or camels or sheep he would take the zakaah that was due on them. Al-Mudawwanah, 1/361.

What the person said, that the zakaah on gold does not have to be paid each year, is indicative of his ignorance. He has to be taught what is correct.

The Muslim should not hasten to issue fatwas on the basis of what he thinks, rather he should refer to the sayings of the scholars and imams so that he can find out what scholarly consensus says and not deviate from it.

And Allaah knows best.

Islam Q&A

4 Responses to “Zakat PJ Refuted”

  1. Shan says:

    Peace be with you..

    I’m just a student.
    The imam who said that Zakath must be paid once reject Ijma too. Reject Ijma mean they don’t take it as a source for Islamic teachings. They don’t accept scholarly consensus. So can you please mention profs without Ijma. (For example we have to show evidences from quran itself for people who say Quran alone is enough. )

    • Admin says:

      Islam is about Quran and Sunnah as understood by the Salaf.. ie the Sahabah, Tabieen, Tabetabiyeen…

      Ijma of the Salaf or first three generations is important..

      We shouldnt go to prove from Quran only or Hadith only for the doubts.. but rather explain that Quran and Sunnah together as understood by the Salaf is deen… InshaAllah

    • Sheik Abdullah says:

      Brother shan, There are Many Sahih Hadith for Every Year you should give zakat. Check the Volume # 3, Book of Zakat, Sunan Nasaii, There are Many Sahih Hadith which explains you have to give yearly. You can download the soft copy at or… Ali Rahiyallahu Anhu Narrates that the Messenger of Allah S.A says, When you possess 200 dirhams, and 1 year passes on them, 5 dirhams are payable. Nothing is incumbent on you, that is On Gold, till it reaches 20 dirhams. When you possess 20 dirhams and 1 year passes on them, half a dinar is payable.Whatever exceeds, that will be reckoned properly. Book#3 – Book of Zakat, Hadith#1568, Abu Dawud. Allah says in the Quran,Those who give not the zakat and they are disbelievers in the Hereafter – Surah Fussilat, ch#41, verse #7.

  2. Sheik Abdullah says:

    It was Narrated that Aishah R.A said, I heard the Messenger of Allah S.A say, There is no ZAKAT on a wealth until Hawl(one year) passes on them. Volume#3, Chapter#5 One who acquires wealth, Hadith#1792, Sunan Ibn Majah (Hasan).. This book Sunan Ibn Majah is translated by Darussalam.. You can download the soft copy in and websites. Kalamullah has Bukhari, Muslim, Tirmidhi, Nasaii, Ibn Majah, Abu Dawud, Ahmad(only 3 Volumes)… May Allah guide you to right path !!!

Leave a Reply